The Premier League’s Best Ever Goalkeepers – Legends Between the Posts
From Peter Schmeichel to Alisson Becker, the Premier League has seen some legendary goalkeepers. Here’s a look at the greatest shot-stoppers in Premier League history.
The Premier League’s Best Ever Goalkeepers
In football, goalkeepers are often the unsung heroes. While strikers grab the headlines for scoring goals, it’s the goalkeepers who make the game-saving stops that win championships. In the history of the Premier League, some goalkeepers have defined eras, breaking records, winning trophies, and delivering performances that will never be forgotten.
From Peter Schmeichel’s dominance at Manchester United to Alisson Becker’s modern-day heroics at Liverpool, let’s look at the greatest goalkeepers in Premier League history.
1. Peter Schmeichel (Manchester United, 1991-1999)
When talking about the best goalkeepers in Premier League history, Peter Schmeichel is often the first name mentioned.
Why He Was Great:
✅ Commanding presence in the box
✅ Excellent shot-stopper and leader
✅ Famous for his one-on-one saves
Schmeichel was the backbone of Manchester United’s dominance in the 1990s. He led United to five Premier League titles and was a key part of the famous 1999 Treble-winning team. His leadership and ability to pull off impossible saves made him one of the most feared goalkeepers in the world.
His legendary starfish save technique was a nightmare for strikers, and many still consider him the best goalkeeper the Premier League has ever seen.
2. Petr Čech (Chelsea, 2004-2015 & Arsenal, 2015-2019)
Few goalkeepers in history can match Petr Čech’s record. He was the foundation of Chelsea’s rise to dominance under José Mourinho.
Why He Was Great:
✅ Holds the Premier League record for most clean sheets (202)
✅ Conceded just 15 goals in the entire 2004-05 season
✅ Four-time Premier League winner
Čech was almost unbeatable in goal for Chelsea. In his first season, he kept 24 clean sheets and conceded just 15 goals in 38 games—a record that still stands today.
Even after suffering a horrific head injury in 2006, he returned stronger, playing at the top level for over a decade. His consistency and ability to perform in big matches make him one of the greatest goalkeepers in Premier League history.
3. David de Gea (Manchester United, 2011-2023)
At his peak, David de Gea was arguably the best goalkeeper in the world.
Why He Was Great:
✅ Four-time Manchester United Player of the Year
✅ Won the Premier League Golden Glove in 2017-18
✅ Made some of the most spectacular saves ever seen in the league
Despite playing in one of Manchester United’s most inconsistent eras, De Gea single-handedly won games with world-class reflexes and shot-stopping. His performance against Arsenal in 2017 (where he made 14 saves in a single match) is one of the greatest individual displays by a goalkeeper in Premier League history.
4. Alisson Becker (Liverpool, 2018-Present)
Modern football requires goalkeepers to be not just shot-stoppers, but also playmakers. No one does this better than Alisson Becker.
Why He Is Great:
✅ Won the Premier League with Liverpool in 2019-20
✅ Golden Glove winner in his debut season
✅ One of the best goalkeepers with the ball at his feet
Alisson is the perfect modern goalkeeper—he makes crucial saves while also being excellent with his distribution. His calmness under pressure helps Liverpool build from the back, making him a vital part of Jürgen Klopp’s team.
And let’s not forget his unbelievable headed goal against West Brom in 2021, making him the only goalkeeper in Premier League history to score a match-winning goal!
5. Edwin van der Sar (Fulham 2001-2005, Manchester United 2005-2011)
After Peter Schmeichel, Manchester United struggled to find a world-class goalkeeper—until Edwin van der Sar arrived.
Why He Was Great:
✅ Won four Premier League titles with Manchester United
✅ Kept a record-breaking 14 consecutive clean sheets in 2008-09
✅ A calm and composed presence in goal
Van der Sar was already a top-class goalkeeper at Ajax and Juventus before joining Fulham in 2001. However, his real greatness was shown at Manchester United, where he played a crucial role in Sir Alex Ferguson’s second dominant era.
At the age of 38, he helped United win the league while setting a record for the longest run without conceding a goal (1,311 minutes). A true legend.
6. Joe Hart (Manchester City, 2006-2018)
Joe Hart may not have the same legendary status as Schmeichel or Čech, but at his peak, he was England’s best goalkeeper.
Why He Was Great:
✅ Four-time Golden Glove winner (2009-10, 2010-11, 2012-13, 2014-15)
✅ Key part of Manchester City’s first-ever Premier League title in 2011-12
✅ Incredible shot-stopper with great reflexes
Hart was Manchester City’s goalkeeper during their rise to dominance, winning multiple league titles. His performances in the 2011-12 title-winning season helped City edge past Manchester United in a dramatic finish.
Although his career declined in later years, his peak years were truly world-class.
Honorable Mentions
- Jens Lehmann (Arsenal) – The goalkeeper of the Invincibles.
- Brad Friedel (Blackburn, Aston Villa, Tottenham) – One of the most consistent keepers in the league.
- Pepe Reina (Liverpool) – Won the Golden Glove three times in a row.
- Shay Given (Newcastle, Man City, Aston Villa) – One of the most underrated keepers in history.
- Hugo Lloris (Tottenham Hotspur) – A World Cup-winning captain with incredible reflexes.
Who Is the Premier League’s Greatest Goalkeeper?
Choosing the best goalkeeper in Premier League history is difficult. If we had to pick:
🏆 Peter Schmeichel – The most dominant
🏆 Petr Čech – The most consistent
🏆 David de Gea – The best shot-stopper
🏆 Alisson Becker – The best modern keeper
🏆 Edwin van der Sar – The coolest under pressure
Ultimately, each goalkeeper was great in their own way. But if we talk about who had the biggest impact, Schmeichel and Čech stand out as the greatest of all time.
Who do you think is the best Premier League goalkeeper ever? Let us know!
Support AW8 and keep the passion alive! ⚽